Lite version. This site best experienced with a standards compliant browser.

Skip Navigation and view content.

NY State exonerations list

29 good reasons not to bring back the death penalty to our state.

Of these, 24 are based on DNA evidence.

1. Habib Wahir Abdal – Buffalo
Convicted, 1983, of a 1982 rape and sentenced to 20 years to life
Served 16 years, Exonerated 1999
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification, government misconduct

2. Roy Brown- Cayuga County
Convicted, 1992, of a 1991 murder, sentenced to 25 years to life
Served 15 years, Exonerated 2007
Factors leading to conviction: Inadequate forensics

3. Leonard Callace - Suffolk County
Convicted, 1987, of sexual abuse, wrongful imprisonment, criminal weapons possession, in a 1985 incident, sentenced to 25-50 yrs
Served 5½ Years, Exonerated 1992
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification, inadequate forensics

4. Anthony Capozzi- Buffalo
Convicted, 1987, of rape, sodomy, sexual abuse in a 1985 incident, sentenced to 11-35 years
Served 20 years, Exonerated 2007
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification

5. Terry Chalmers - Westchester
Convicted, 1987, of rape and sodomy in a 1986 incident, sentenced to 12-24 years
Served 7 ½ years, Exonerated 1995
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification

6. Charles Dabbs - Westchester
Convicted, 1984, of rape in a 1982 incident, sentenced to 12 ½ - 20 years
Served 7 years, Exonerated 1991
Factors leading to conviction: Eyewitness misidentification

7. Lynn DeJac - Buffalo
Convicted, 1994, of murder in a 1993 incident, sentenced to 25 years - life
Served 13 ½ years, Exonerated 2008
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, investigator failures

8. Jeffrey Deskovic- Westchester
Convicted, 1990, of murder and rape in a 1989 incident, sentenced to 15 years – life
Served 15 ½ years, Exonerated 2006
Factors leading to conviction: False confession, government misconduct

9. Scott Fappiano - Brooklyn
Convicted, 1985, of rape and sodomy in a 1985 incident, sentenced to 20-50 years
Served 21 years, Exonerated 2006
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification

10. Hector Gonzalez - Manhattan
Convicted, 1996, of a 1995 murder, sentenced to 15 years to life
Served 5 ½ years, Exonerated 2002
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification

11. Dennis Halstead - Nassau County
Convicted, 1987, of murder and rape in a 1984 incident, sentenced to 33 1/3 years to life
Served 16 years, Exonerated 2005
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, false confession, investigator misconduct

12. John Kogut - Nassau County
Convicted, 1986, of murder and rape in a 1984 incident, sentenced to 31 ½ years
Served 17 years, Exonerated 2005
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, false confession, investigator misconduct, informants, snitches

13. Kerry Kotler - Suffolk County
Convicted, 1982, of a 1982 rape, sentenced to 25-50 years
Served 10 ½ years, Exonerated 1992
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification, inadequate forensics, government misconduct

14. Antron McCray - Manhattan (Central Park Jogger incident)
Convicted, 1989, of rape and assault in a 1989 incident, sentenced to 5-10 years
Served 6 years, Exonerated 2002
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, false confession

15. Michael Mercer - Manhattan
Convicted, 1992, of rape, sodomy and robbery in a 1991 incident, sentenced to 20 ½ to 41 years
Served 10 ½ years, Exonerated 2003
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification

16. Alan Newton - Bronx
Convicted, 1985 of a 1984 rape, robbery, assault, sentenced to 13 ½ to 40 years
Served 21 years, Exonerated 2006
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification

17. James O'Donnell - Staten Island
Convicted, 1998, of sodomy and assault in a 1997 incident, sentenced to 3 ½ to 7 years
Served 2 years, Exonerated 2000
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification

18. Victor Ortiz - Newburgh (Orange County)
Convicted, 1984 of rape and sodomy in a 1984 incident, sentenced to 25 years
Served 11 ½ years, Exonerated 1996
Factors leading to conviction: eyewitness misidentification

19. John Restivo - Nassau County
Convicted, 1987 of murder and rape in a 1984 incident, sentenced to 33 1/3 years to life
Served 16 years, Exonerated 2005
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, investigative misconduct, false confession, snitches

20. Kevin Richardson - Manhattan (Central Park Jogger case)
Convicted, 1990, of attempted murder, rape, sodomy and murder in a 1989 incident, sentenced to 5-10 years
Served 5 ½ years, Exonerated 2002
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, false confession, government misconduct

21. Yusef Salaam - Manhattan (Central Park Jogger Case)
Convicted, 1990, of rape and assault in a 1989 incident, sentenced to 5-10 years
Served 5 ½ years, Exonerated 2002
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, false confession, government misconduct

22. Raymond Santana - Manhattan (Central Park Jogger Case)
Convicted, 1990, of rape and assault in a 1989 incident, sentenced to 5-10 years
Served 5 ½ years, Exonerated 2002
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, false confession, government misconduct

23. Douglas Warney - Rochester
Convicted, 1997, of a 1996 murder, sentenced to 25 years to life
Served 9 years, Exonerated 2006
Factors leading to conviction: False confession

24. Kharey Wise - Manhattan (Central Park Jogger Case)
Convicted, 1990, of assault, sexual abuse, riot in a 1989 incident, sentenced to 5-15 years
Served 11 ½ years, Exonerated 2002
Factors leading to conviction: inadequate forensics, false confession, government misconduct

Based on evidence other than DNA

25. Jose Garcia - Bronx
Convicted, 1993, of a 1991 murder
Served 15 years, Exonerated 2007
Factors leading to conviction: Defense attorney failures (Defense attorney did not pursue conclusive evidence that Garcia was in the Dominican Republic at the time of the crime

26. Barry Gibbs - Brooklyn
Convicted, 1988, of a 1986 murder, sentenced to
Served 19 years, Exonerated 2005
Factors leading to conviction: Corrupt police investigators. Coerced misidentification

27. Olmado Hidalgo- Manhattan (Palladium murder case)
Convicted, 1992, of a 1990 murder, sentenced to 25 years to life
Served 13 years, Exonerated 2005
Factors leading to conviction: Eyewitness misidentification

28. David Lemus- Manhattan (Palladium murder case)
Convicted, 1992, of a 1990 murder, sentenced to 25 years to life
Served 13 years, Acquitted at retrial, 2007
Factors leading to conviction: Eyewitness misidentification

29. David Wong – Clinton County
Convicted, 1992, of a 1990 murder, sentenced to 25 years to life
Convicted, 1987, while serving a sentence for robbery, of the 1986 murder of an inmate at Dannemora, sentenced to 25 years to life
Served 17 years, Conviction overturned, charges dismissed 2004
Factors leading to conviction: Eyewitness misidentification